
Streaming of students in secondary schools into vocational and academic pathways presents as a significant stumbling block to university access and the objectives of the Accord.
In a new paper looking at the impact of school streaming on university participation, Griffith U’s Andrew Harvey, Lucy Campion and Rebecca Wren found streaming was an effective barrier to participation for Indigenous students and other unrepresented cohorts.
The team looked at data across four States, revealing some significant disparities. Only 6% of Indigenous students in WA receive an ATAR, comparted to 73% of non-Indigenous students in NSW, at the other end of the spectrum.
While streaming was designed to facilitate student choice and the pursuit of relevant pathways, in reality, “the practice is likely reinforcing stereotypes and contributing to unequal postsecondary outcomes,” the authors write.
“In Queensland, 65% of ATAR students transition to HE, compared with just 5% of the non-ATAR cohort. The school sector is thus central to HE growth and equity but also to tertiary harmonisation.”
“We find that the practice of streaming is extensive, that groups such as Indigenous students are highly over-represented in vocational streams, and that very few students in vocational streams transition directly to higher education.”
The authors also found that when non-ATAR students did enrol in HE, their success rates and employment outcomes were lower.
While streaming was designed to promote student choice, implementation effectively reduced mobility between VET and HE and entrenched reduced esteem for VET, the authors said.
They also point to significant issues with data gaps. “The lack of publicly available data around the extent of ATAR streaming and the postsecondary outcomes of students, including Indigenous and other marginalised groups, is concerning and limiting to the analysis of policy efficacy,” they write.