
Yesterday, Luke Sheehy called on a meeting of HE policy insiders to come up with a “serious, credible and ambitious alternative” to the failed present model – he meant Job Ready Graduates.
It is late in the day to get the lobbies into developing an alternative student funding model.
ATEC’s Stephen Duckett has been working for a year on a higher education equivalent of the activity based efficient price model he was instrumental in introducing to hospital systems. “The proposed framework will inform the provision of evidence-based costing and pricing advice from the ATEC to government on options to establish a new way of funding CSPs in universities,” is the idea. Responses to a discussion paper are due mid-December.
There are already big contributions ahead of the debate in detail that will follow the Duckett prop. In July, Gwilym Croucher and Mark Rahimi from Uni Melbourne’s Centre for the Study of Higher Education proposed an evidence-based costing-model, to do what does not happen now, include the “different structural circumstances” of universities – regional and research-intensive tech-heavy and teaching-focused. They proposed eight different provider types to use in a model of structural costs.
So why did UA and CSHE round-table yesterday with ATEC, DoE and MPs advisers over a debate that is underway? FC does not know – UA did not return his call but suspects the reason is the debate over establishing teaching costs does not cover the two issues universities really want to talk about.
One is Job Ready Graduates. “The Minister has criticised it. The opposition has called for a review. JRG is a policy without friends. And yet, somehow, it survives,” Mr Sheehy said.
“The challenge now is to agree on what should replace it. Because replacing bad policy requires more than a compelling critique. It requires a credible alternative.”
Which is what an efficient cost model will not create. ATEC has always been upfront that JRG is not included in work on funding models “It does not determine final funding amounts, student contribution settings, the Commonwealth-student cost-sharing proportions or implementation timings,”
The other is how research is funded. “Research expenditure may be examined (but only) to understand teaching costs, cost allocation practices and the relationships between teaching, scholarship and research.” “The funding of research and research training is outside the scope of this work.” Mr Sheehy did not mention reforming research funding it is embedded in one way or another in allocations for Commonwealth Supported Places.
And so Mr Sheehy calls for answers to three bigger questions;
* What does it actually cost to deliver a quality university education?
* How do we fairly share the cost between government and students?
* What happens after students graduate? “how much graduate debt is reasonable?
How should repayments work?”
What he wants is a funding system that is “fairer for student and properly funds universities.”
Which leaves two questions.
How to define “fairer” and what will “properly funded” universities cost.